The Unusual Tale of Mary & Joseph’s Baby (Songs from the Musical)

Just a Jew (Joseph)

I Want to Be Delivered (Mary)

Hello, Mary (The Angel)

I Don't Know That She Wants What I Want (Joseph)

Eggplant Casserole (Benjamin)

Joseph's Never Gonna Believe Me (Mary)

Magnificat (Elizabeth & Mary)

Hello, Joseph (The Angel)

Herod's Way (Micha & Avigail, the Inkeeper & His Wife)

My Part of the Story (Joseph)

The Space Between (Mary)

Birthing Checklist for Sheep And/Or Fathers (Naphtali, the Shepherd)

Magnificat Reprise (Mary, Joseph, Midwife, and Naphtali)

Sleepy Deepy, Poopy Sheepie (Mary & Joseph)

Why Does God Have to Look so Human (Mary & Joseph)

O, Great Light (Magus, as in the Singular of Magi)

Put a Little Faith in Me (Joseph)

Get out of Herod's Way (Micha, Avigail, Joseph, Mary)

No, Just Go (The Angel)

Just the Messenger (Joseph & the Angel)

Whose Baby Is He? (Mary)

Walk Through the Sea on Dry Land (Benjamin, Elizabeth, Joseph, Mary)